Archives 2025

The Pro’s and Con’s of increasing the VAT bracket within South Africa in 2025

The South African Parliament recently unveiled the South Africa VAT increase as part of the 2025 Budget, introducing significant fiscal measures to address the nation’s economic challenges. A central component of this budget is the proposed increase in the Value-Added Tax (VAT) rate, aimed at enhancing revenue streams to fund essential public services.

The Pro’s and Con’s of increasing the VAT bracket within South Africa in 2025

Key Highlights of the 2025 Budget:

• Incremental VAT Increase: The government plans to raise the VAT rate by 0.5 percentage points in 2025/26 and an additional 0.5 percentage points in 2026/27, elevating the rate from 15% to 16% over two years.

treasury.gov.za

• Allocation of Additional Revenue: The increased VAT revenue is earmarked for critical sectors, including:
  
  
  • Healthcare: An additional R28.9 billion is allocated to address the needs of the country’s large HIV-positive population and to fund medical personnel salaries.

apnews.com

• Defence: An allocation of R5 billion to strengthen military forces in response to regional conflicts.

apnews.com

• Social Services: Funding for early childhood education and the revitalization of commuter rail transport.

pwc.co.za

• Support for Low-Income Households: To mitigate the impact of the VAT hike on vulnerable populations, the government proposes expanding the list of VAT zero-rated essential food items and maintaining current fuel levy rates.

treasury.gov.za

Pros of the VAT Increase:

1. Revenue Generation: The VAT hike is projected to generate an additional R72 billion over the next two fiscal years, bolstering the government’s capacity to fund essential public services and infrastructure projects.

pwc.co.za

2. Fiscal Sustainability: By increasing VAT, the government aims to reduce the budget deficit, stabilize public debt, and achieve a primary fiscal surplus, thereby enhancing the country’s economic stability.

pwc.co.za

3. Targeted Social Relief: Expanding the list of VAT zero-rated items seeks to protect low-income households from the regressive nature of consumption taxes, ensuring that necessities remain affordable.

treasury.gov.za

Cons of the VAT Increase:

1. Inflationary Pressure: South Africa VAT increase hike may lead to increased prices for goods and services, exacerbating the cost-of-living crisis and eroding real wages, particularly among low- and middle-income consumers.

lexology.com

2. Economic Slowdown: Higher consumption taxes could reduce household spending, potentially slowing economic growth and adversely affecting businesses reliant on consumer demand.

lexology.com

3. Political Opposition: The proposed VAT increase has faced resistance from major political parties and labour unions, raising concerns about potential delays in budget approval and the risk of political instability.

lexology.com

Implications of Raising the VAT Bracket:

The decision to implement the South Africa VAT increase 2025 reflects the government’s strategy to enhance fiscal capacity amidst economic challenges. While the additional revenue is intended to fund critical public services, the regressive nature of VAT necessitates measures to protect vulnerable populations. The expansion of VAT zero-rated items is a targeted approach to mitigate adverse effects on low-income households.

However, the potential inflationary impact and political resistance underscore the need for a balanced and inclusive fiscal policy that promotes economic growth while ensuring social equity. The 2025 Budget’s proposed VAT increase presents both opportunities and challenges. Its success will depend on effective implementation, stakeholder engagement, and complementary policies that collectively aim to foster sustainable economic development and social well-being.

Why does the U.S. prioritise stronger ties with Ukraine over South Africa when it comes to securing its mineral supply?

In today’s rapidly evolving geopolitical landscape, access to critical minerals is a key factor influencing international relations. The United States, a global leader in technology, defence, and clean energy, relies heavily on a stable supply of essential minerals to maintain its industrial and strategic edge. This raises an important question: Why are U.S. mineral imports from Ukraine over South Africa prioritized when securing critical resources?

The USA’s Mineral Landscape: What They Have and What They Lack

The United States is home to vast natural resources, but when it comes to critical minerals—those essential for defence, semiconductors, and renewable energy—it faces significant shortages. The U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) reports that the country is heavily dependent on imports for 50+ minerals, including rare earth elements, cobalt, lithium, and graphite.

Minerals Abundant in the USA:

• Copper – Essential for electrical wiring
• Gold & Silver – Used in electronics and currency reserves
• Zinc & Lead – Important for construction and battery production

Minerals the U.S. Heavily Depends on Imports For:

• Lithium – Vital for EV batteries and renewable energy storage
• Nickel – Used in stainless steel and battery technologies
• Cobalt – Critical for aerospace and battery production
• Rare Earth Elements (REEs) – Necessary for high-tech applications, including defence systems

The U.S. currently imports more than 80% of its rare earths, with China dominating global supply chains. This dependency poses a significant national security risk, prompting the U.S. to seek alternative sources in friendly nations.

Why Ukraine Over South Africa?

Despite South Africa’s wealth in platinum, gold, and rare earth minerals, U.S. mineral imports from Ukraine over South Africa continue to be prioritized due to geopolitical and economic factors. However, political instability, power crises, and South Africa’s alignment with BRICS nations (Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa) make it a less favourable ally for Washington.

Key Factors Driving U.S. Preference for Ukraine:

1. Ukraine’s Vast Mineral Reserves
   Ukraine is home to one of the largest lithium reserves in Europe, along with significant deposits of titanium, nickel, and rare earths. These resources are crucial for the U.S. and its allies as they look to diversify away from Chinese and Russian supplies.
2. Geopolitical Alignment
   Ukraine is firmly aligned with the Western bloc, especially after the Russian invasion. The U.S. has provided billions in aid to Ukraine, and securing mineral resources in the region supports its broader economic and security interests.
3. Sanctions and Trade Restrictions on China & Russia
   As tensions rise between the U.S. and China, Washington is actively reducing reliance on Chinese supply chains. Since South Africa maintains strong economic ties with China and Russia through BRICS, the U.S. is hesitant to increase trade in strategic minerals with a country that could favour its geopolitical rivals.
4. Ukraine’s Need for Post-War Reconstruction
   With significant U.S. investment flowing into Ukraine, securing mineral rights in the country helps rebuild its economy while simultaneously benefiting American industries looking for a reliable, Western-aligned supply source.

Where Will the U.S. Get Its Minerals?

To reduce reliance on adversaries like China, the U.S. is expanding its global partnerships in mineral-rich regions:

Canada & Australia – Trusted allies with vast lithium, cobalt, and rare earth resources
Ukraine – Growing focus due to its untapped reserves
Latin America (Chile, Argentina, Bolivia) – The “Lithium Triangle” supplies over 50% of the world’s lithium
Africa (excluding South Africa) – Countries like Namibia and the Democratic Republic of Congo are becoming preferred suppliers of cobalt, uranium, and copper

Although South Africa is a mineral powerhouse, the trend of U.S. mineral imports from Ukraine over South Africa persists due to trade risks and political factors. As Washington seeks to secure critical minerals for defence, technology, and clean energy, it is turning to Ukraine, Canada, Australia, and Latin America—nations more aligned with Western interests.

For South Africa to remain competitive, it must strengthen its trade policies, improve infrastructure, and diversify partnerships beyond BRICS. Otherwise, it risks losing out on lucrative deals in the evolving global mineral landscape.

How Implementing DOGE Could Transform South Africa’s Government Efficiency

The past few weeks have been eventful in global politics, with South Africa’s government efficiency under scrutiny. The annual budget announcement took a dramatic turn when opposition parties learned of a proposed 2% VAT increase by the ANC. This decision would place additional financial pressure on the country’s most vulnerable populations.

Meanwhile, the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) in the USA has sparked global debate with its radical efficiency measures. This raises an important question: Could South Africa implement a similar model to improve its government efficiency?

South Africa Government Efficiency: How DOGE Can Transform Public Services

If South Africa were to adopt a DOGE-inspired approach, it would need to align with the country’s socio-political landscape, economic conditions, and governance structures. Below is a strategic framework for how South Africa Government Efficiency could be dramatically improved.

Defining Clear Objectives for South Africa Government Efficiency

To successfully implement DOGE, South Africa must establish clear and measurable objectives:

• Eliminating Bureaucratic Red Tape: Reduce inefficiencies in government services to accelerate public service delivery.
• Digital Transformation: Implement AI, automation, and blockchain to modernise public sector processes.
• Cost Optimisation: Reduce government waste while maintaining essential services.

Establishing Transparent & Accountable Governance

For DOGE to succeed, South Africa’s government efficiency reforms must be transparent and free from political interference. This includes:

• Independent Oversight: DOGE should operate autonomously under parliamentary oversight.
• Diverse Leadership: Leaders should come from public and private sectors, academia, and civil society.
• Provincial & Local Integration: DOGE must coordinate across national, provincial, and municipal levels for seamless implementation.

Key Sectors to Improve South Africa Government Efficiency

Certain government departments would greatly benefit from DOGE reforms:

• Home Affairs: Automate ID and passport applications to reduce waiting times.
• Healthcare: Streamline procurement for hospitals and clinics to ensure timely access to medicines.
• Education: Digitise textbook distribution and expand e-learning solutions.
• Revenue Services (SARS): Use AI-driven tax collection systems to enhance compliance and efficiency.

Implementing Gradual & Inclusive Reforms

To avoid resistance, South Africa’s government efficiency reforms should be implemented gradually:

• Pilot Programs: Test reforms in select departments before full-scale implementation.
• Stakeholder Engagement: Work with unions, businesses, and local communities to minimise pushback.
• Skills Development: Train public servants in digital tools, data analysis, and change management.

Leveraging Technology for Government Efficiency in South Africa

Digital transformation is at the core of DOGE-style governance:

• E-Government Portals: Centralise public services online to reduce queues and paperwork.
• AI & Machine Learning: Automate fraud detection, resource allocation, and citizen feedback analysis.
• Blockchain for Procurement: Ensure transparent, corruption-free government contracts.

Data Privacy & Cybersecurity: Protecting Government Systems

With digital transformation, safeguarding sensitive government data is crucial:

• Robust Cybersecurity: Secure IT infrastructure to prevent data breaches.
• Data Governance Compliance: Ensure strict adherence to POPIA (Protection of Personal Information Act).

Legal & Regulatory Considerations for Efficient Government Reform

To align DOGE reforms with existing laws:

• Review Labour Laws: Ensure efficiency programs do not violate labor protections.
• Ethical AI Use: Establish clear guidelines for AI-driven government decision-making.

Public Communication & Cultural Shift Towards Efficiency

For reforms to succeed, public awareness and engagement are essential:

• Transparent Communication: Provide regular updates on DOGE’s goals and progress.
• Public Participation: Citizens should have a platform to suggest improvements in government services.
• Cultural Change: Encourage performance-based incentives for government employees.

Monitoring & Evaluating Government Efficiency in South Africa

To ensure long-term success, continuous evaluation and adaptation are necessary:

• Performance Dashboards: Use real-time, public dashboards to track government KPIs.
• Third-Party Audits: Conduct independent assessments to measure effectiveness.
• Iterative Improvements: Regularly refine strategies based on feedback and measurable outcomes.

Potential Challenges & Solutions in Improving South Africa Government Efficiency

• Resistance from Labour Unions: Engage unions, offer retraining programs.
• Corruption Risks: Strengthen internal controls and whistleblower protections.
• Digital Divide: Invest in affordable internet and rural digital infrastructure.

Would South Africa Benefit from a DOGE-Like Government Efficiency Model?

The potential impact of DOGE on South Africa’s Government Efficiency is immense—but success depends on thoughtful, well-planned implementation.

By embracing AI, blockchain, digital transformation, and automation, South Africa can modernise governance, improve service delivery, and eliminate corruption. However, it must also balance efficiency with job security and social responsibility.

Would you support a DOGE-style approach to South Africa’s government efficiency? Let us know your thoughts in the comments!